A few weeks ago, Timberland contacted me about the opening of their new store on Newbury St. As part of the opening, Timberland will award a $2,500 “Earth Day” grant this April to a local community organization dedicated to environmental stewardship, which is pretty cool.
They also offered me the chance to review one of three pairs of shoes available in the Newbury Store. All three feature Bionic canvas for extra durability and ion-mask technology by P2i for ultra water repellency, but the choice wasn't difficult. I fell hard for the Earthkeepers Cabot L/F Tall Zip Boot.
Though I never really considered Timberlands fashionable, I was pleasantly surprised when I saw these boots. Not only were they super cute, they were waterproof and perfect for April in Boston.
Some specifics about the boots:
- Tall Zip: Inside zipper for easy entry
- Premium leather and strong Bionic® canvas upper for long-lasting wear
- Bionic® canvas contains yarns made with a 50% organic cotton outer wrap, 38% recycled PET core and 12% HT polyester to provide increased strength, abrasion resistance and decreased dry time
- Hydrophobic breathable materials combined with ion-mask™ technology by P2i shed water easily
- 100% recycled PET lining for climate control and breathability
- Leather-covered footbed for optimal comfort
- Lightweight, flexible, undercut rubber outsole for maximum traction and durability is made with 15% recycled rubber
Now, it's very hard for me to write negative reviews on my blog, and in fact, I think this may be a first. Though the boots are super cute, they're IMPOSSIBLE to put on. Literally, I had to jam my foot into them to get them on. Maybe it's because the actual foot part is shallow, or because the zipper doesn't go down low enough (which is weird, because it goes pretty far), but it shouldn't take 5 minutes to put on a pair of boots.
Sure, maybe they'll stretch with wear, but I'm not sure I'm ready to risk it- they're just so stiff! Plus, my feet ended up covered in blisters. (Granted, the first time I wore them I was wearing ankle socks, but still.) When I tried to give them a second chance, it still took forever to put them on, and the rubbing against the irritated blisters did not help.
When I talked to Timberland's very responsive social team on Twitter and asked if they'd seen other unsatisfied customers, they remarked that the boot runs a half size small. As much as I want to believe a size 6.5 would fit better, there was still a ton of room in the front of the size 6.
Though these boots are cute, they're definitely not cute enough to be uncomfortable. I found myself walking on my toes in order to avoid rubbing my heels on the back of the boots, and struggling to tuck my jeans into them because they lacked any stretch.
Maybe it was just me, and maybe I need to give them another chance, but I think I'll pass. At $170, I think you should too.
Thanks for thinking of me, Timberland. I loved the style of the boots, but the comfort factor just didn't cut it.
Photo c/o Timberland.